Greetings from the midst of my
Finnish Summer Theatre Tour! I'm not yet finished with my Finnish summer series, but something else has been on my mind recently, so I wanted to discuss that in English today.
Let's talk about
bootlegs.
Self-made recordings of theatrical productions that fans share and exchange with each other, that is. Illegal and forbidden, of course – but wrong altogether? I'm not so sure.
|
Text without pictures looks boring, but I don't have any related images.
So here's my Jekyll & Hyde fancomic instead. Part 1. |
Personally, I am against pirating things you can buy. I think if you enjoy someone's work, you should support them. Buy the CD or the DVD, pay to download the files, subscribe to Spotify or Netflix. The artists of course only get a small slice of the profit, but even so, they're getting more than from illegal downloads.
But what about things that cannot be bought? There are no legal recordings available for most musical productions. Official videos happen once in a blue moon and most CDs feature Broadway or West End casts. That being the case, is there harm in fans sharing audience recordings of their favourite productions? Well, as long as you don't bother the actors or other audience members while recording – and that is really important, there is no excuse for distracting others in theatre – I don't think so.
Sure, there are good arguments that speak against bootlegging. Theatre is not meant to be captured, it's a part of its magic to change and disappear. The actors might object to being filmed if they knew someone's recording the show. Bootlegging breaks copyright. Important things to consider, but after having thought about them, I'm still personally okay with bootlegs.
The way I see it, and I know many other theatre fans share this thought, bootlegs mainly profit people who cannot see the show any other way. People who can't afford tickets, people who live too far from the theatre to visit, fans of shows that have already closed. I don't think anyone's losing any profit here. I've never heard of anyone who, if they had the chance to see something live, would still prefer sitting in front of a laptop, peering at a shaky blurry image.
Bootlegs also capture something that usually fades away. For hundreds of years, all theatrical performances were lost forever. Now we can save small examples of some of them and enjoy them for years to come. Some think that is the complete opposite of what theatre's about. I see their point, but even so, I feel there's something comforting about the thought.
For the record, I am not a big bootleg person myself. I've of course watched a handful of illegal videos, mostly of German shows (some of those were so inspiring I
travelled to Germany for the live experience). But they're a rare treat, something to be enjoyed only every now and then. I after all prefer Finnish theatre.
You see, in Finland, bootlegging is not a thing. Finnish theatre culture is different from West End, Broadway or Central European theatre
cultures, and that also applies to bootlegs. Maybe there are recordings of Finnish shows somewhere, but they're not generally available, not listed in fans' collections and certainly not on Youtube.
In Central Europe especially, the musical fan culture, the bootlegging that comes along with it, and even the theatres' attitudes towards their own videos are more laid back than here in the north.
Musical fans' collections and even Youtube are full of not only Central European bootlegs but also pro-shot videos (meaning performances filmed by the theatre, often with multiple cameras and careful editing). I don't know who is leaking these videos, but in a way, it almost seems like a form of advertising. Slipping a video online, hoping people get excited and visit the theatre for real to see more.
I believe that works. As said, me and my friend travelled to Germany because we found a new favourite actor via bootlegs and leaked pro-shots. And imagine if we were German! We'd probably take the train to see him every weekend.
I don't see why there couldn't be an active fandom for Finnish musicals, like there is in some other European countries. But I believe that fandom could use some bootlegs to grow. Having updated
Fuck Yeah, Finnish Musical Theatre! for over three years now, I've read plenty of comments wishing there was a video of this or that production available. Sometimes from foreigners. Oftentimes from Finns.
I'm not saying anyone should take the risk and start filming. I'm just wondering – in theory, might having easy access to bootlegs create new buzz, attract new audiences to theatres around here? No one knows for sure, but as you can expect, I'm guessing it would.
|
Part 2. |
That's about it for my personal thoughts about bootlegs. What do you think? Please let me know in the comments. Are you for or against bootlegs, and why? And, if there are any actors reading this – what would you think if you encountered fans sharing a bootleg featuring your performance?